# Behavioral interview question: proposing an idea that was not agreed on

Aced (formerly Exponent) publishes a public search API over its indexed pages; the guide is at https://www.aced.io/agents/agent-access.

Source: https://www.aced.io/questions/1366/time-proposed-idea-not-agreed
Source observed: 2026-11-04T21:35:00.059Z
Last checked: 2026-11-04T21:35:00.059+00:00
Indexed: 2026-11-05T01:17:33.23+00:00

---

# Tell me about a time when you proposed an idea that was not agreed on.

We provide this behavioral interview question with community answers, interview context, related questions, and preparation resources. The question is tagged **Behavioral** and is associated with Product Manager, Software Engineer, and Data Scientist roles. It has **7 interviews** and was reported last asked **9 months ago** at the time shown on the page.

## Member access

Membership includes:

- 100+ expert answer videos
- Access to all courses
- Peer-to-peer practice
- Private Discord community
- Full question database

[Upgrade](https://www.aced.io/upgrade?src=questions) · [Upgrade now](https://www.aced.io/upgrade?src=questions)

## Interview experience

One shared experience is listed:

- [Apple · 9 months ago](https://www.aced.io/experiences/apple-senior-software-engineer-interview-74c1ad) — Software Engineer, Senior / L5. The hiring managers asked many questions about Java internals, Java build-system internals, Maven versus Gradle behavior, and networking internals including HTTP versus HTTP/2.

## Community answers

The page lists **11 community answers**.

### Aishwarya J. — June 16, 2025

A proposed approach would have pushed the completion ETA back by a few days because the project required collaboration among product, engineering, and design. The delay affected the required OKRs and led to less productive or actionable outcomes, although the approach had a detailed implementation method that would not require refinement.

[View Aishwarya J.’s profile](https://www.aced.io/users/cf117083-805e-4245-9eef-ef5b867e797e) · 378 karma

### Sam — September 19, 2021

> Disagreement → persistent → more data insights → positive relationship → mentor/trust

[View Sam’s profile](https://www.aced.io/users/edd0b0df-b143-44f9-b839-b0aa63f787c9) · 208 karma

### Adam C. — October 31, 2024

Adam asks whether an interview answer must end with the interviewee on the losing side. He worries that describing a situation in which the team rejected his decision but later failed could sound like “I told you so,” even when that is not the intended message. He asks how to avoid that impression in a short conversation.

[View Adam C.’s profile](https://www.aced.io/users/d087b518-1543-457c-b650-33d1e45b1f9f) · Member · 527 karma

### Umang S. — May 29, 2022

**Context:** Umang joined midway through development of a large public-facing tool. The team proposed iterations, while clients pushed their own priorities.

**Problem:** User-research feedback was deprioritized, design feedback was not considered, and the client relationship became one-directional. Umang proposed bringing user-research and design feedback forward and prioritizing work by customer value, but clients rejected the proposal and continued to push their own priorities and feature elements.

**Action:** Umang suggested an experimentation framework to address the clients’ lack of trust after a long period without a product manager. The team onboarded Optimizely and selected a low-value iteration for an A/B/C experiment:

- **A:** Control
- **B:** Client design
- **C:** Team design using user-research and UX feedback

**Result:** B and C initially trended above A, and C achieved statistical significance by the end of the experiment. The experiment created a way to test competing opinions with real users, helped clients understand the value of feedback and data, and showed the team that user and subject-matter-expert feedback can be combined. The answer reports an **11% increase in user retention**, exceeding the product’s North Star expectations.

[View Umang S.’s profile](https://www.aced.io/users/6a85e9df-f0f7-4bfa-a948-56b3a94f17fc) · 982 karma

### Shivananda S. — October 19, 2024

Shivananda says that, in this situation, they would work on the business scenario with an example and make sure the proposed ideas were agreed upon by the business.

[View Shivananda S.’s profile](https://www.aced.io/users/0a5ed9a9-272e-4416-9996-a36af81fb7bb) · 253 karma

## Related questions

- [Tell me about a time when you took an idea to launch.](https://www.aced.io/questions/138/example-launch-idea)
- [Tell me about a time when you resolved a problem that was outside your team’s scope.](https://www.aced.io/questions/1935/solving-problem-outside-team-scope)
- [Tell me about a time when you worked well on a team.](https://www.aced.io/questions/2967/positive-teamwork-experience)

## Related courses

### [Data Science Interview Prep](https://www.aced.io/courses/data-science)

We cover mock interviews, frameworks, and advice from senior candidates, including statistics, experimentation, coding, SQL, machine learning, and behavioral interviews for roles at Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Meta, Apple, and other companies.

![Data Science Interview Prep](https://images.ctfassets.net/x78yjrjc11pq/3U4C5C0OkDR0UeGch4AmlE/7ad489430b676a088cb973307fe77884/Data_Science_Interview_Prep_Course.jpeg?w=800&h=800&fm=webp&q=75)

### [SQL Interviews](https://www.aced.io/courses/sql-interviews)

We cover SQL syntax basics, aggregations, window functions, complex queries, and analysis of diverse datasets.

![SQL Interviews](https://images.ctfassets.net/x78yjrjc11pq/62mN54S54HpLIOmyG8qbnq/54deaf5e397d0807d71c0e27e21e5ee3/sql_illustration_2.jpg?w=800&h=800&fm=webp&q=75)

## Practice

You can submit an answer to mark the question complete or [Practice with AI](https://www.aced.io/practice/ai/new?type=Behavioral&question=time-proposed-idea-not-agreed&src=questions).

---

[Read this page’s summary](https://www.aced.io/agents/api/public/v1/page-tldr?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aced.io%2Fquestions%2F1366%2Ftime-proposed-idea-not-agreed&trace=t_679ff9ab98f3)

## Ask a follow-up about this page

Need a more specific answer? Ask the exact question you have. It returns a fresh, cited answer from Aced (formerly Exponent)’s knowledge base. No account or API key required.

Open this URL with your own question, URL-encoded. Include your question in q. All research inputs are optional; no account or setup.

`GET https://www.aced.io/agents/agent/faq?q={question}&trace=t_679ff9ab98f3`

[Tool guide and examples](https://www.aced.io/agents/agent-access) · [OpenAPI](https://www.aced.io/agents/api/public/v1/openapi.json) · [Page TLDR form](https://www.aced.io/agents/agent-tools/page-tldr?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.aced.io%2Fquestions%2F1366%2Ftime-proposed-idea-not-agreed). Opening a form does not execute a tool.